Week 2 Football Pick’em Contest Strategy & Advice (2026)

Expert tips and picks for Week 2 football pick’em contests, where we look forward to some key overreaction spots from the public.

KANSAS CITY, MO - SEPTEMBER 14: Denver Broncos cornerback Riley Moss (21) blocks a pass intended for Kansas City Chiefs wide receiver Xavier Worthy (1) during the first half on September 14th, 2026 at Arrowhead Stadium in Kansas City, Missouri. (Photo by William Purnell/Icon Sportswire)

The Broncos had a rough Week 1, and draw another tough matchup with Jacksonville in Week 2.

We’re back with updated strategy and advice for Week 2 of the 2026 season. This column serves as a complement to our Football Pick’em Picks product, which combines public pick popularity data with our modeling to recommend the best picks for your pool.

Each week, we’ll break down tactics to help you gain an edge in both NFL and college football pick’em contests. We’ll also explain the reasoning behind some of the picks our premium product may highlight — especially when the smart play goes against the grain.

This post will be updated throughout Week 2 with fresh insights and late-breaking notes. Here’s what’s available so far:


Sunday 9/20

Sunday AM Pick Overview

Here’s your Sunday AM Pick Overview, and some teams we have strong positions on in either game winner or spread pools.

This is a week with a lot of bigger favorites, only two games feature win odds for the favored side under 60%. So our season-long pools are on the favorites, and in confidence point pools, the win odds differences will largely control how points are assigned.

Weekly Game Winner

The underdogs that move up the most in the weekly picks format are:

  • Arizona 59.3%
  • Cincinnati 58.5%
  • Jacksonville 42.8%
  • NY Jets 30.6%

So we see only two outright upsets appearing in over half of weekly pick top options, with Jacksonville slightly under.

Spread Pools

In spread pools, we see the following as the most highly recommended across all pools. Just remember, individual results may vary depending on things like contest line.

TeamATS Max Profit
Pittsburgh100.0%
Carolina99.9%
Arizona99.8%
Miami99.7%
Minnesota99.6%
Cleveland99.4%
Indianapolis99.3%
NY Giants96.9%
Tennessee90.2%

and here is the same for weekly ATS. where popularity impacts more:

TeamTop Option
Arizona99.9%
Pittsburgh99.9%
Minnesota99.8%
Miami99.7%
Indianapolis99.7%
Cleveland99.4%
Tennessee99.6%
NY Jets99.0%
Washington98.8%
New Orleans97.6%

Wednesday 9/16

Week 2 Value Picks to Consider

Last week, we started 3-1 with our value picks, and it was a big part of why our Maximum Profit picks averaged 12.7 wins in Week 1, compared to a public average of 9.8, and also why 23% of our subscribers who have checked in so far this week have reported winning a weekly prize for the first week.

Let’s get back to it with some picks to consider for leverage in Week 2.

This week gives us a lot of bigger favorites, as nearly half the favorites are favored by 6.5 or more points, and only three games feature a spread of 3 or lower. That makes for some extreme pick rates on the favorites.

1. Arizona Cardinals (vs. Seattle)
Spread: +4.0 | Win Odds: 35.0% (Vegas) / 36.4% (PG) | Pick Popularity: 8.0%

Seattle enters as the reigning Super Bowl champs, but starting QB Sam Darnold left Week 1 with a hip injury and will sit this one out — Drew Lock is the starter in relief. Arizona, meanwhile, did the opposite of what a rebuilding team under new coach Mike LaFleur was supposed to do in Week 1: Jacoby Brissett went 27-of-37 for 277 yards and a touchdown in a road upset win over the Chargers, where the score line was no fluke, as Arizona controlled the game, pressured Chargers QB Justin Herbert, and won in all phases. With the model liking Arizona more than Vegas does and barely 1 in 12 entries on them, this is the widest gap on the board.

2. New York Jets (vs. Green Bay)
Spread: +3.5 | Win Odds: 36.7% (Vegas) / 34.4% (PG) | Pick Popularity: 11.0%

The Jets’ Week 1 win over Tennessee wasn’t just a final score — they put up 367 yards of offense, a number their offense never got within shouting distance of at any point in the back half of last season, while holding the Titans under 200 total yards. Green Bay, by contrast, lost its opener 39-22 to Minnesota, managing just 3.1 yards per carry (still without Josh Jacobs) and getting Jordan Love sacked four times, even with a few explosive completions to Christian Watson mixed in. Green Bay is also still missing Micah Parsons (ACL, out into October). The Jets may have the actual line-of-scrimmage advantage here, and the public — sitting at 89% on Green Bay — hasn’t caught up to that at all.

3. Carolina Panthers (at Atlanta) — Favorite at a Reasonable Price
Spread: -2.5 | Win Odds: 56.4% (Vegas) / 61.4% (PG) | Pick Popularity: 66.0%

Carolina’s defense was torched for 59 points in Week 1 (the highest-scoring Week 1 game in NFL history), but Bryce Young and the offense answered with 37 of their own against a good Bears team. Atlanta enters with real uncertainty at quarterback — Tua Tagovailoa (oblique) and Michael Penix Jr. (recovering from a torn ACL) were both out in Week 1, forcing journeyman Cooper Rush into a spot start, with Penix’s return timeline still unclear. This is the week’s biggest riser in model conviction, jumping up to a higher confidence play in weekly formats, while being one of the shortest spreads of the week.

4. LA Rams (vs. NY Giants) — Favorite at a Reasonable Price
Spread: -7.0 | Win Odds: 75.8% (Vegas) / 74.0% (PG) | Pick Popularity: 82.0%

The Giants carry a real story pulling public support their way — a new Harbaugh-run staff, a promising rookie season from Jaxson Dart, a healthy Malik Nabers — but at 18% pick popularity as a touchdown underdog, they’re actually drawing more relative support than several shorter dogs elsewhere on the board. (Arizona, for example, is being picked less than half as often as the Giants). The Rams’ Week 1 results could be providing relative value to just stay on the favorite here. They had an ugly loss in Australia, Myles Garrett is on IR after knee surgery, and the Giants looked good in primetime, all contributing to some relative public sentiment on the Giants, compared to other bigger dogs.


Tuesday 9/15

Week 2 Early Matchups Overview

Our value picks segment will be coming to you on Wednesdays, so check back for the games where we are seeing value for Week 2. (Last week, we highlighted the Jets, Chiefs, Vikings, and Texans.)

Here’s how Week 2 is shaping up.

Big Favorites (6)

  • San Francisco (-13.5) vs. Miami
  • Tampa Bay (-8.5) vs. Cleveland
  • Baltimore (-8.5) vs. New Orleans
  • LA Rams (-7) vs. NY Giants
  • LA Chargers (-7) vs. Las Vegas
  • Philadelphia (-7) at Tennessee

San Francisco returns from spending a week in Australia and plays a Miami team that is the lowest-rated in the league. Tampa Bay, meanwhile, faces the team that looked like the worst team in the league after Week 1, in Cleveland, and we would expect extreme low popularity on the Browns as well.

Two of the biggest disappointments of Week 1, the two Los Angeles teams, are still bigger favorites of a touchdown this week, and both facing teams that won a week ago. That could lead to some interesting pick dynamics, where a few more people are willing to pick the underdog.

Moderate Favorites (7)

  • Kansas City (-6.5) vs. Indianapolis
  • Chicago (-5.5) vs. Minnesota
  • New England (-5.5) vs. Pittsburgh
  • Seattle (-4.5) at Arizona
  • Buffalo (-4.5) vs. Detroit
  • Green Bay (-3.5) at NY Jets
  • Dallas (-3.5) vs. Washington

We have an interesting mix of games here, and the value in this range could decide some pools this week. Kansas City is at the top end, coming off a big MNF win, and playing again at home on a short week. Chicago scored 59 points and faces a Minnesota team with QB uncertainty after Carson Wentz had to replace Kyler Murray after he suffered an early concussion on Sunday.

Seattle is favored over Week 1’s biggest upset king in Arizona, but that line is much shorter than it would have been, both because of Arizona’s performance, and Seahawks QB Sam Darnold’s injury, which should at least keep him out for this week.

Buffalo won a close game in a shootout over Houston, while Detroit had to go to overtime, and the two open the week on Thursday Night Football.

Green Bay and Dallas are both favored by just over a field goal right now and coming off losses, so we’ll see how the public responds to these very popular franchises after a disappointing first game.

Short Favorites (3)

  • Houston (-3) vs. Cincinnati
  • Denver (-2.5) vs. Jacksonville
  • Carolina (-1.5) at Atlanta

There are only three matchups of a field goal or less this week, and these types of games usually provide the higher leverage opportunities if public sentiment swings one way.

The game that provides that potential is Denver against Jacksonville, where the public was heavily on the Broncos last week given their road underdog status, but the games for these two could not have gone more differently.

In the Carolina-Atlanta game, meanwhile, we await to hear who will start at QB for Atlanta this week.


Tuesday 9/15

Week 1 Results

Week 1 was a strong week for our recommendations across the board, most notably in game winner season-long pools, and the gap between our picks and the public was larger than usual.

In Game Winner pools, our Max Profit picks averaged 12.7 wins, well ahead of the public’s 9.8. In ATS pools, Max Profit picks averaged 8.9 wins to the public’s 7.5, a solid gain on average of over one win..

That 2.9-win edge in Game Winner play for a single week is an extremely positive result. Extrapolated across a full 18-week season (that gap won’t hold — variance alone guarantees it) it would result in a massive performance versus the typical pool participant. Even a fraction of that margin compounding over a season is the difference between a middling year and competing for a pool win.

We also expect fairly high reported weekly win rates based on that number, at least in pools that have both prize types. The weekly game winner Top Options came in below the Max Profit, but still more than a win ahead of the public.

Much of that edge came from correctly leaning into a handful of games where our numbers and public perception were furthest apart, and otherwise having most of the bigger favorites win. (The one big upset, Arizona, was not popular anywhere and thus not that costly if you did not pick them.)

Where we were right:

  • NY Jets — our models had them at 95%+ in both Game Winner and ATS pools, while the public gave them just 24.5% and 38% respectively. The Jets won outright, and our models said they should have been the slight favorite instead..
  • Minnesota — 95.8% our side in Game Winner, 37% public. The Vikings came back and won as one of the smaller favorites of the week.
  • Washington — 89.3% on the ATS side to just 25% public. Washington covered, and just missed a chance to tie it late with a failed two-point attempt.
  • Arizona — 93.7% on the ATS side to 36% public. Arizona not only covered, but won outright.
  • New Orleans and New England ATS also covered spreads in relatively unpopular spots.
  • Kansas City in game winner and spread, where the public was taking Denver more often in game winner and far more heavily in spread pools.

Where we missed:

  • Cleveland — we were at 89.9% on the ATS side to just 28% public, on the bigger spread. Jacksonville covered handily — our biggest single miss of the week.
  • Tampa Bay, Miami, Indianapolis, and Houston ATS also missed, and we were much heavier on all the dogs compared to the public, though none as extreme as Cleveland.

FYI

Important Notes About Picks We Highlight

A few things to keep in mind about the picks we highlight in this article:

  • Not all picks are right for all pools. Strategy depends on your pool’s size, format, and prize structure. A smart pick in a large weekly pool might be a poor choice in a small season-long contest.

  • We focus on strategy and value, not just who will win. The goal is to beat your opponents, not just pick winners. That often means identifying low-popularity favorites or fading trendy upset picks with low upside.

  • Data can shift before game time. We publish sections based on the most current win odds and pick popularity at the time, but those numbers can change — especially with injury news or line movement.

We’ll update this post if any major shifts occur. For the most up-to-date recommendations tailored to your pool, check out the Football Pick’em Picks product. It updates multiple times daily and adjusts for your specific rules and opponents.

You can see the latest information in the Data Grid.

After you generate customized picks for your pool, you can also update those pick recommendations whenever you want via the My Pool Picks screen. The updated picks will incorporate the most recent data we have.


FYI

About Our Pick’em Pool Advice

Our Football Pick’em Picks product doesn’t give one-size-fits-all advice — because the best pick depends on your pool.

Things like pool size, scoring rules, weekly vs. season-long prizes, and even your current standing all impact pick strategy. That’s why we built technology to analyze your specific pool settings and generate customized pick recommendations.

As far as we know, we’re still the only site offering fully strategy-driven picks tailored to your format and goals.

The result? 71% of our subscribers win a prize (season-long or weekly) in a football pick’em contest each year.

If you haven’t set up your pool in the product yet, you can do that in minutes — just enter your rules, and we’ll handle the rest.

While this article highlights key strategy and pick dynamics, your actual best picks may differ — and that’s by design. To get your edge, use the product.

We hope you enjoy reading, and we encourage you also to check out more of our football pick’em strategy articles.

Free 3-Day Premium Trial

Premium Sports Picks

Betting - Survivor - Pick’em

Start Free TrialGet The Season

Running Your Own Pool?

Picksheet, operated by TeamRankings, gives you many ways to run your group’s pool: